Friday, October 11, 2013

[Preview] FiiO E18 Kunlun – Surprise, Surprise.

The E18 Kunlun is the latest portable amp/DAC for our favoritest budget amp company FiiO. Different from the E17, the new E18 is built for pretty much exclusive for Android devices. Well, it does work as a USB DAC on PC or as a standalone amp, but being an Android DAC is what it really is all about.





Spec
The E18 I have is an early sample that should perform the same as the retail version. However the official spec has yet to be released, so instead I will add the detail in once they are available.



Accessories and Build Quality
The packaging is fairly similar to any other FiiO products in the market now, which is basically a white and red hard paper box. Most of the accessories are pretty standardized as well, including a microUSB charging cable, 3.5mm interconnecting cable, some rubber band to hold the amp to the source, an S/PDIF adapter cable similar to that from X3 (as E18 can output S/PDIF coax), some stick-on rubber feet, a soft pouch, some simple manual, as well as the all importable micro-to-microUSB interconnecting cable. One thing to complain is the microUSB interconnecting cable – while it works fine, it is too short and only designed for smartphone with microUSB port on the top or bottom. For me as a Sony Xperia user, that’s bad news since Sony usually places the microUSB port on the side. It would have been much better if FiiO would include a few more microUSB cable with different angle and length. Right now I have to look for an alternative cable so I can actual stack the two devices together.




The remote buttons are not (from left) Previous, Next, Play, but actually Next, Previous, Play.



Build quality is pretty much on par with previous FiiO products. The design is somewhat dull compared to E17, but at least it is still well built. Size wise, it is about the same as the E12 so it is by no mean small. However, it won’t be bigger than most of the top-of-the-line Android phone out there. On one end, there are the volume knob (which double as on/off switch), the 3.5mm headphone-out, the 3.5mm input (which double as line-out with the DAC function) The gain switch, and the bass boost switch. You will also find the three remote control buttons (Play/Pause, Next/Forward and Previous/Backward) on the side. On the other end, there are the S/PDIF out, and two micro USB port – one for charging the E18, the other one for either DAC or power bank function depends on the switch just next to the microUSB port. On top, there is an LED for DAC indication as three LED for battery capacity.

One thing to note, E18 can act as a USB DAC or a power bank (to charge you smartphone, etc), but not at the same time. It is important never to connect the port to a PC when it is in power bank mode, as it could lead to damage.

Last but not least, the three remote control buttons works quite well in the both PC and Android. The ability to skip / pause music without turning the smartphone’s screen on is quite useful, same goes for PC remote control. However, the marking is a bit confusing. Instead of ‘back / forward / play’, it is actually ‘forward / back / play’. No biggie but it does seem odd at first.




The 3.5mm analog-in also double as line-out for the DAC.



Gain, Hiss and EMI
E18 has two gain setting. Low gain is about +1dB and high gain is about +7.5dB. E18 is pretty much dead silence when it comes to hiss. It does pick up some mild EMI, but not enough to be a big concern unless you absolutely can’t stand any EMI – which will be a tall order given the source is most likely going to be a smartphone.

Battery Life
E18 has a 3500mAH li-ion battery that can pump out some juice to charge your device if you choose to. As I have said before, it will be wise never to connect the microUSB port to a PC when it is in power bank mode, since you can’t really recharge a PC.

I haven’t had the time to do a full battery test, but the big battery does look like it can almost out last a modern day smartphone when used together.

Sound Quality
Let talk about some of the hardware first: as far as I know, the DAC chip is TI PCM1795, which is one of the better DAC from TI and capable of 32bit 192kHz decoding. But because of the Tenor TE7022 as USB receiver, it will be limited to 24/96 at most. This is if you are running it from PC. On Android, you might not get the full 24/96 but limited to 16/44.1 depends on what your Android can support. DAC aside, E18 runs on an opamp+buffer amp section, which are OPA1612 + dual LMH6643 and should give it a comparable performance to E17 in theory.


White = pure amp; Green = PC's USB DAC; Blue = Green with Bass Boost; Purple = Android DAC on Xperia TX with Power Amp music player; Yellow = Same as Purple, but using Neutron Music Player.

As usual, I did some RMAA measurement on the E18. Because E18 can acts as USB DAC for PC and Android, as well as a standalone amp or a line-out source, I repeat the test quite a few times under different configuration. Both most occasions, either as pure amp or as DAC, E18 has very low noise and good dynamic, easily comparable to Leckerton Audio UHA-4 which I used for reference. As pure amp, E18 is flat from 50Hz to 20kHz, but has a very slight +0.5dB bump from 50Hz down to 20Hz. As either PC or Android DAC (w/ Power Amp), E18 still maintain the same flatness from 50Hz up, but instead has a very slight -0.5dB roll-off from 50Hz down to 20Hz. The deviations are all very mild on all three cases, so there isn’t much to concern. However, for some unknown reason, Neutron Music Player seems not to play well with E18 as it has much more obvious roll-off (-1dB @ 20Hz and -3.5dB @ 20kHz). This is likely caused by conflict between Neutron internal audio engine and the DAC driver. As much as I love Neutron as a music player on my Android, I’ll really advice against it if you are using E18. Output impedance is measured and calculated to be less than 1 ohm. Current output is similar to that of E17, and should be more than enough for even very low impedance load. Line-out is measured to be around 1.25Vrms, which isn’t particularly high (though higher than most iDevice line-out). Max headphone-out (high gain) is measured at around 3Vrms, good for most but probably not for the really high impedance, low sensitivity load.


Size comparison (from left): Sony Xperia TX, E18, FiiO X3, Nano 7G.


Size comparison (from left): C&C BH2, E18, E12.

Let starts with the DAC section first. As far as subjective listening go, the DAC section carries some of the classic TI’s DAC flavor – that is, it has excellent texture and timbre over the mid and bass range, giving a very mild tone of warmth and forwardness. This is quite the contrast to ESS Sabre that is often very clean and open, which gives really good space but tends to be on the lean side. Beyond the different characteristics of the DAC, I’ll say the PCM1795 is just an equal match to any ES9023 based DAC. If you are coming from a Sabre DAC, you might find a more closed in soundstage and lesser upper detail. But in exchange you will get better lower texture and vocal detail. There isn’t a clear winner here in my opinion.

How about the amp section? Quite excellent, actually. I volume matched the E18 to JDS Labs C5, Leckerton UHA-4 (OPA209) and FiiO’s own E12, then them a listen. For overall refinement and resolution, E18 is pretty much on the same level. The only area that is not as good is on the soundstage. While it is quite good, it isn’t nearly as grand as the others. This makes E18 probably the 2nd best sounding amp in current FiiO’s line-up of portable amp, just after E12. If E18 has the equal soundstage to match, I would think E12 might not be the king of the mountain anymore.

EQ
Bass boost begin just under 1kHz and peaks around 55Hz @ +5.3dB before rolling back down to +3.5dB @ 20Hz. It actually looks quite similar to the bass boost on older FiiO product. It behaves quite well, since the majority of the boost is in the sub-200Hz region. In essence, you will get a good dose of rumbling with an adequate amount of boominess.


The included USB cable isn't ideal for the TX, but it will work.

Sum-up
So far we have covered just about everything on the upcoming E18, so what is the surprise I have mentioned on the title? Well, if you have been chasing Android news as much as I do, you probably should know that USB Audio is supposed to be part of the Jelly Bean. Yet, besides some flagship devices from big brand that comes with their own custom built USB audio driver, the sad news is most of Jelly Bean devices just won’t detect USB DAC. It is a sad situation that I have experienced with my Xperia TX (JB 4.1.2). I have tried as many USB DAC as I could, but as usually, it keep telling me the USB DAC is drawing too much power, even when I have the USB DAC powered externally. Something in the stock Android USB audio driver or the OS itself seems to be missing, and I even started to doubt whether there is actually a stock USB audio driver or not – then comes the E18, takes my doubt away and turns it into joy. Now my TX has been transformed to a proper audiophile player. Okay, the sound quality isn’t quite as good as a DX100 or HM901, but it sure is more than good enough for day to day listening and way better than the smartphone itself. There is no guarantee that your Android will work, but there is more hope than ever. If anything, I reckon this is just about as close as a ‘must have’ for any Android user who suffer from a sub-par headphone-out on their smartphone.

A thank to FiiO for the sample.

16 comments:

mark9104 said...

very interesting. I am a Sony phone user as well and although the sound quality is ok, I do find the output a bit weak

Angel Torrado said...

Can't wait to have this bad boy on the market. It's gonna replace my E07K. Great job Fiio, it looks like if your best products so far.Can't wait to have this bad boy on the market. It's gonna replace my E07K. Great job Fiio, it looks like one of your best products so far.

Scrypt said...

Thanks very much for the detailed comparisons in your so-called preview (which was more thorough than many people's reviews!).

One question: You seem to be saying that the DAC section of the E18 is equal to but not necessarily better than the E17's. Did I understand that correctly? It sounds as though, in choosing the E18, one sacrifices a bit of soundstage and high-end detail for warmth and lower mid and low-end detail. The better amp, more modern features, greater compatibility and battery charger make this an easy purchase, but as I happen to prefer high-end detail and soundstage to bass information, your comments about the weighty sig give my me and my mailmen a pause.

Tai / ClieOS said...

I am saying the measurement indicates the E18 is, performance wise, should be on par with E17. It doesn't mean they will sound the equal. RMAA is a very simple measurement tool and it can only reveal fairly limited information. In actual listening, E18 is still better, on both DAC and amp.

Scrypt said...

Good to ken, Tai/Clie!

Ashneel99 said...

I have a TX as well, sucks I can't use my ODAC with it :/

aarondouglas said...

Have you found a cable to be able to stack the E18 with an Xperia Z? I just received my E18 and this is definitely an issue...

Tai / ClieOS said...

No, can't say I have.

Eugene du Toit said...

How does the amp section compare to E12? I remember you said that it was little worse than the E12. Do you still feel this way? I was looking at the portable X3, but most of my music o the go these days are from Spotify, so my best bet would be something that can connect to my windows phone with line out and computer with Essence ST. I had the O2, its a great amp but too bulky for pockets. How does the E18/E12 compare to in from a sound " flavor". My only compliant with the O2 was there seems to be less impact and prat than some others I have heard. I however did find it to be very clean sounding. I later changed my desktop amp to Xonar E1 and have been pleased with it. I do not really need the DAC section from the E18, but if the performance of it and the E12 is quite close its much better value for money. Earphones are all the 32 ohm range.

Tai / ClieOS said...

My opinion usually doesn't change with time - and yes, I still think E12 is the best of all the FiiO, while E18 is the 2nd. Actually if you don't need the DAC section, I am not sure why you will want the E18, consider that E12 is actually cheaper.

Eugene du Toit said...

That was quick!The price from amazon.co.uk has only very small price difference. Is the E12/E18 more dynamic sounding than O2? Is it more portable then the O2? I probably do not need the DAC section but if there is only small price difference then it could be handy. Thank you for your time and patience!

Tai / ClieOS said...

They are definitely more portable than O2, but I won't say either is better sounding, O2 has set quite a high standard for any portable amp to cross. You can spend up to $500 and might not find an portable amp that is noticeably better than O2. FiiO's amps tend to be just a little warmer sounding and not quite as wide on soundstage as they can be.

Eugene du Toit said...

Thank you Tai! I did not think that these are beter sounding than O2 In this case portability is more important than ultimate SQ so I am will to compromise. Which one of the E18/E12 would you think is more weighty/faster sounding? My earphone are SE215 and Phonak Audeos.

Tai / ClieOS said...

Both are just as fast, but E12 is a bit more weighty.

tropico said...

Great article. May I ask about most suitable solution for my case. I'm looking for portable AMP/DAC for my ATH-M50, M-Audio Q40 and JVC HA-SZ2000. Currently my source is laptop (home), work pc, Sansa Clip+ and iPhone 5S.
I know that FiiO E12 has better subbass boost and this is what I'm looking for, but it doesn't have DAC which I critically need too.
In future I want to change Clip+ for something better - FiiO X5 or something from iBasso players and as I understand the best option for me now is FiiO E18 or FiiO X5 (as it has amp and dac). Could you please point me at correct direction.

Tai / ClieOS said...

Between the two, I am definitely going to recommend X5 first. While there is nothing wrong with E18, you will be better off with a good source first, which is less restraining.

Post a Comment

Amazon's Deal

Disclaimer: All trademarks and logos in the website belong to their respective owners. Beside getting free review samples, I don't work for or get paid by anyone to write anything on this website, or anywhere else in that matter. Also, free review samples are never sold for any financial gain. I do buy gears and review them, but for simplicity you (the reader) should always assume what I review is free sample in nature (and thus comes with all the bias). The website does have Google Ads and Amazon Associates enabled (which I have no direct control over their content) - though I don't write review for a living, nor does the ads generates enough money to cover my breakfast (in fact, not even one breakfast per week). Listening to music and playing with audio gears are purely hobby for me. In short, I am just an audiophiles who happens to have his own blog. Not a journalist who happens to be an audiophile. Oh, and excuse my writing as I am not a native English speaker and can't afford a proofreader. Also, just because I don't write in a negative tone doesn't mean I don't write down the negative aspect of a gear. Please read them carefully.

Important: All postings are my own personal opinion only and should not be treated as absolute truth. I do get things wrong just like everyone else. Always do your own research!

Lastest Posts

Latest Comments

 
Copyright 2008-2014 In Ear Matters. Powered by Blogger Blogger Templates create by Deluxe Templates. WP by Masterplan